Page 27 - IAT_April_2025_Magazine
P. 27
that can compromise their impartiality. The for disclosure and management should be in place
following are some situations in which COIs could in internal audit departments. The policy should
occur: contain:
• Personal Relationships: If an internal auditor • Regular COI evaluations for all auditors,
has close family, friendship, or love links especially when beginning a new project.
with someone in the department or area • Advice on what to do in the event that a COI is
being audited, this might lead to conflict. The discovered, including necessary paperwork and
auditor’s judgement may be viewed as biassed reporting protocols.
or influenced by such relationships. • Clear guidelines for maintaining independence
and impartiality.
• Financial Interests: Having any kind of
financial interest in the company under audit, 2. Continually Declare Possible Conflicts
including shares or payments, may give rise
to a conflict. It can cast doubt on the auditor’s When dealing with conflicts of interest, transparency
independence even if the financial interest is is critical. Any professional, financial, or personal
minimal. interests that can be interpreted as conflicts of
interest must be declared by internal auditors. This
• Previous Employment or Consultancy: It may include:
could be challenging for the auditor to maintain
objectivity if they have previously worked for • declaring financial assets, including ownership
the department or area under audit or have of company stock.
offered consulting services to that area. Because • sharing information about connections with
of their prior engagement, the auditor may have management or staff in the audit area.
a biassed evaluation or their impartiality may • reporting any previous participation in the
be called into question. audited field (for example, consulting or
managerial positions).
• Management or Decision-Making Role: If the • maintaining a current disclosure record that is
internal auditor has been or is now involved periodically reviewed by top audit leadership.
in management decisions, such as policy • auditors show their dedication to transparency
formulation or financial decision-making, they by revealing possible conflicts of interest up
should not audit such decisions. front, which enables the organisation to decide
how best to proceed with the audit.
• Other Business Interests: The auditor’s
objectivity may be called into doubt in cases 3. Establish Recusal Procedures.
where they have other business interests, such
as a position in a rival company or involvement Recusal (withdrawal) from an audit engagement
in other partnerships. may be required if a conflict of interest is discovered.
An auditor should step away from the task and let
Practical Strategies for Internal Auditors an unbiased colleague conduct the internal audit if
to manage Conflict of Interest they are unable to be totally neutral. This ensures
that the audit process maintains its integrity.
A proactive strategy is needed to manage conflicts
of interest. Internal auditors must be cautious in
recognising and eliminating potential conflicts of
interest as early as possible. The following strategies
may help the auditors in overcoming this challenge:
1. Create and enforce a clear COI policy
A well-written policy that outlines what a conflict
of interest (COI) is and offers precise guidelines
INTERNAL AUDIT TODAY 24
