Page 37 - iiA
P. 37
uneven, and retaliation against whistleblowers is • Trend analysis and escalation of repeat issues
still widespread in various regions. across departments or regions.
Europe’s Regulatory Push • Reputation preservation through timely
corrective action.
Europe made a significant leap with the EU
Whistleblower Protection Directive (2019/1937), Integrated properly, whistleblower reports can feed
which mandates that public and private into enterprise risk management (ERM), offering
organisations with 50+ employees establish critical insight into vulnerabilities that traditional
internal reporting systems. Member states were audits or top-down reviews might miss.
required to transpose this directive into national
law by December 2021. Organisations with over Lessons from High-Profile Cases
50 employees to implement secure internal
reporting channels and protect whistleblowers Across continents, whistleblower disclosures have
from retaliation. shaped the trajectory of entire industries:
While the Directive is a milestone in harmonising • Danske Bank (EU): A whistleblower revealed
protections, its implementation has been over €200 billion in suspicious transactions,
fragmented. Some countries have been slow to prompting sweeping reforms in anti-money
comply, and the quality of internal systems varies laundering (AML) compliance across Europe.
widely. Nonetheless, the Directive positions
whistleblower programs as part of a broader risk • Wirecard (Germany): Despite persistent
governance strategy, encouraging both internal internal and external warnings, institutional
(within organisations) and external (regulators, blind spots led to one of the largest corporate
media) reporting paths and offering recourse fraud cases in EU history. The resulting scandal
when internal mechanisms fail. led to the restructuring of Germany’s financial
oversight body, BaFin.
Some countries such as France, Germany, and
the Netherlands have gone further, embedding • SEC (USA): More than $1 billion has been
whistleblowing into broader corporate governance awarded to whistleblowers, with tips leading
frameworks. Others have taken a minimalistic to high-impact enforcement actions against
approach, creating inconsistencies in practice and corporate fraud and market manipulation.
enforcement. Nevertheless, Europe now stands at
the forefront of a global push to institutionalise These examples underscore a consistent lesson:
whistleblower reporting as an essential element of whistleblower systems can prevent or precipitate
organisational risk management. crisis, depending on whether organizations listen
and act.
From Reporting to Risk Communication
Whistleblower systems are increasingly valued
not just for surfacing wrongdoing, but for
communicating risk internally, in real-time, and
often ahead of external scrutiny.
Key Functions of Whistleblower
Programs as Risk Tools:
• Early warning signals for compliance breaches,
fraud, harassment, and safety violations.
• Real-time feedback from within the
organization, bypassing formal bottlenecks.
INTERNAL AUDIT TODAY 34
